Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York State

Best Pizzerias in Middle Island

Price
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility

21 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of La Volpe Ristorante restaurant
1. La Volpe Ristorante
4.7
Exceptional(977)
$$$$
• Pizzeria • Center Moriches
Booked 17 times today
Nestled in the heart of Center Moriches, La Volpe Ristorante offers an exceptional Contemporary Italian dining experience that has captivated locals and visitors alike. Celebrated for its "fantastic culinary adventure" and the perfect marriage of Executive Chef Franco Volpe's "creative contemporary style" with his mother Maria Teresa's cherished traditional recipes, this restaurant is truly a gem. Guests rave about the "excellent food and service," highlighting the fresh seafood, all-natural meats, and hearty pastas that grace the eclectic menu. The inviting atmosphere paired with an "award-winning wine list" ensures that each visit is memorable, making La Volpe a must-visit destination for Italian cuisine enthusiasts.
A photo of Pietro's of East Meadow restaurant
2. Pietro's of East Meadow
4.8
Exceptional(1034)
$$$$
• Pizzeria • East Meadow
Booked 16 times today
Pietro's of East Meadow is a must-visit for those seeking authentic Pizzeria cuisine. Celebrated as the "Home of the Original Sesame Seed Crust Pizza," Pietro's offers a delightful blend of tradition and innovation since 1976. Diners rave about the "incredible staff" and "cozy, welcoming atmosphere," making every visit a memorable one. The unique igloo dining experience adds a festive charm, perfect for special occasions or a cozy night out. With warm, friendly service and a menu that boasts delicious pizzas and more, Pietro's is "one of a kind" and a cherished "cornerstone of East Meadow." A true gem for pizza lovers!
A photo of Emilio's restaurant
3. Emilio's
4.7
Exceptional(708)
$$$$
• Pizzeria • Commack
Booked 14 times today
'Emilio's is a real hometown favorite among locals who stop in for a quick slice of pizza to go, or to sit at one of the high-top tables in the dining room and enjoy freshly prepared dishes like fried calamari, eggplant rolatini, and grilled chicken parmigiana. ' -Commack Patch
A photo of Mary's Pizza & Pasta restaurant
4. Mary's Pizza & Pasta
4.9
Exceptional(205)
$$$$
• Pizzeria • Speonk
Booked 15 times today
Mary's Pizza & Pasta in Speonk serves up an enticing blend of Italian and American cuisine that has captivated locals for over two decades. With a delightful menu that includes everything from perfectly prepared Salmon Picatta to their epic bone-in Veal Parmesan, this family-owned gem is a standout in American dining. Patrons rave about the "awesome food, service, and atmosphere," making it a perfect spot for family dinners or friendly gatherings. The outdoor patio with live music adds to the vibrant atmosphere. With attentive service and reasonable prices, Mary’s offers a memorable dining experience that keeps guests coming back for more.
A photo of Iavarone Italian Kitchen & Pizzeria restaurant
5. Iavarone Italian Kitchen & Pizzeria
4.7
Exceptional(1142)
$$$$
• Pizzeria • Plainview
Booked 37 times today
Iavarone Italian Kitchen & Pizzeria in Plainview is a shining star in the world of Contemporary Italian cuisine, offering diners a delightful blend of traditional and modern flavors. This family-friendly trattoria is celebrated for its "excellent food and amazing service," making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The restaurant's sensational pizzas, classic pasta dishes, and homemade desserts are consistently praised as "delicious" and "satisfying." Guests can enjoy their meals in a cozy dining room or a charming year-round atrium. With a welcoming atmosphere and "outstanding" service, Iavarone promises an exceptional dining experience that keeps patrons coming back for more.
A photo of Sally's Apizza - Stamford restaurant
6. Sally's Apizza - Stamford
4.5
Awesome(222)
$$$$
• Pizzeria • Stamford
Booked 47 times today
Sally's Apizza in Stamford is a standout destination for pizza aficionados, offering an authentic Pizza Bar experience that echoes the legendary New Haven original. Renowned for its "flavorful, crispy, crunchy" thin-crust pizzas cooked to perfection in a coal-fired oven, Sally's uses only fresh, high-quality ingredients that keep patrons coming back for more. The lively, family-friendly atmosphere further enhances the dining experience, making it a local favorite. Acclaimed by diners as having the "best pizza, period," Sally's Apizza ensures a delightful meal with its exceptional service and mouth-watering Italian classics. It's a must-visit for anyone seeking top-notch pizza in Stamford.
A photo of Stellina Ristorante restaurant
7. Stellina Ristorante
4.9
Exceptional(843)
$$$$
• Pizzeria • Oyster Bay
Booked 18 times today
Stellina Ristorante in Oyster Bay is a true gem for lovers of authentic Pizzeria cuisine. Boasting a cozy ambiance that transports diners straight to Italy, this quaint, 40-seater restaurant offers a culinary experience that is both "superb" and "unforgettable." Guests rave about the "amazing" wood-fired oven pizzas, which are crafted with high-quality ingredients and embody the essence of Italy's rich culinary traditions. The pizzas are consistently described as "fantastic" and "delicious," making Stellina a standout in the dining scene. With a passionate staff dedicated to top-notch service, Stellina Ristorante promises a delightful dining journey, leaving diners eager to return.
A photo of The Pie restaurant
8. The Pie
4.5
Awesome(10)
$$$$
• Pizzeria • Port Jefferson
Booked 9 times today
We are one of the few locations on Long Island that serves true authentic coal fired Neapolitan pizza and the only place to get pizza this unique. When the summer months hit, Port Jefferson Village is jumping and the hottest spot in town is The Pie. In the Winter, The Pie is the perfect cozy spot to get together with your loved ones. Whether you are part of the community or just visiting, our family friendly atmosphere is the place to be. Our pizza is hand-crafted thin, crispy, and well done. Each pie is made with only the freshest ingredients served by our courteous staff. A great selection of appetizers, fresh salads, homemade pastas, and desserts there is something here for everybody. We are located in the heart of Main Street, just a short walk from the marina.
A photo of Sally's Apizza - Fairfield restaurant
9. Sally's Apizza - Fairfield
4.7
Exceptional(206)
$$$$
• Pizzeria • Fairfield
Booked 25 times today
Sally's Apizza in Fairfield is a must-visit for pizzeria enthusiasts seeking authentic New Haven-style pizza. Known for its "perfectly charred" thin crust, the pizza here is a delightful blend of high-quality ingredients, cooked to perfection in a coal-fired oven. Reviewers rave about their "best white clam" pizza and the outstanding service that accompanies each visit. The lively, family-friendly atmosphere adds to the charm, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Many patrons find it "as good as Wooster Street in New Haven," ensuring a consistently memorable dining experience. Sally's Apizza is a true gem in Fairfield's dining scene.
A photo of Marys Pizza & Restaurant restaurant
10. Marys Pizza & Restaurant
4.7
Exceptional(59)
$$$$
• Pizzeria • East Islip
Mary's Pizza & Restaurant in East Islip is a hidden gem for seafood lovers, offering a delightful array of authentic Italian seafood dishes that are sure to impress. Diners rave about the "fresh and very tasty" seafood, served in generous portions that leave you with leftovers to enjoy at home. The welcoming atmosphere and attentive service enhance the dining experience, making it a favorite spot for family gatherings and special occasions. Whether you're indulging in a new seafood creation or savoring a classic favorite, Mary's promises a memorable culinary journey that "never disappoints," securing its place as a neighborhood gem.
‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
  • MerryGold
    New York State •66 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 2 days ago
    Four different appetizers and four different entrees! Wonderful dining experience! Couldn’t tell you which dish was the best! A neighborhood gem!!!!
    More info
    La Volpe Ristorante$$$$• Italian• Center Moriches
    •
    4.7
  • Leanora
    New York City •6 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 3 days ago
    This place is always a hit. Great food and even better staff!
    More info
    Pietro's of East Meadow$$$$• Italian• East Meadow
    •
    4.8
  • KristenGold
    New York City •47 reviews
    4.0
    Dined 4 days ago
    We enjoy Ivarone in Plainview and always have a good meal. The ambiance is lovely and service is always great.
    More info
    Iavarone Italian Kitchen & Pizzeria$$$$• Italian• Plainview
    •
    4.7
  • Stephanie
    New York City •24 reviews
    5.0
    Dined on May 21, 2026
    Emilio's was our daughter's choice to celebrate her birthday with her family and we couldn't have been happier. We had a reservation and were seated immediately. The complementary bread and focaccia basket was served quickly and was plentiful and OMG delicious. From the RigatoniBolognese to the Buccatini Pomodoro, Shrimp, Chicken everything was outstanding and we all went home with leftovers.....Thank you!!!!! 
    More info
    Emilio's$$$$• Italian• Commack
    •
    4.7
  • Kathryn
    New York State •2 reviews
    5.0
    Dined on May 12, 2026
    Consistently great food with a nice selection of choices. Nice portions, very pleasant staff from waitress to servers. Never disappoints.
    More info
    Mary's Pizza & Pasta$$$$• Italian• Speonk
    •
    4.9

Explore OpenTable

Discover
OpenTable
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Press
More
Our sites
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2026 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 500, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo