Best Pizzerias in Castlereagh

Price

$$
$$$
$$$$

Regions

BaysideBondi AreaCentral CoastEastern SuburbsInner SouthInner South West

Neighborhoods

AvalonBanksmeadowBondi BeachBondi JunctionBrookvaleCaringbah

Top Rated

CharmingGood for business mealsGood for groupsGood for special occasionsGreat for brunchGreat for fine wines

Dining Options

All dining options

Delivery only

Takeout only

Seating Options

BarCounterStandardHigh TopOutdoor

Accessibility

Wheelchair access

45 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Product of Italy Penrith restaurant

1. Product of Italy Penrith

4.8

Exceptional(196)

$$$$

• Pizzeria • Penrith

Booked 6 times today

Product of Italy Penrith is a beacon of authentic Italian pizza cuisine nestled in the heart of Penrith CBD. Revered for its "perfectly cooked" pizzas, this family-run Pizza Bar offers a tantalizing array of flavors that consistently leave diners raving. Guests frequently praise the "10/10" quality of their pizzas, complemented by a warm and inviting atmosphere. The restaurant's ability to cater to diverse dietary needs, including gluten-free and vegetarian options, ensures everyone can indulge in the delicious offerings. With friendly staff and an ambiance that exudes Italian charm, Product of Italy Penrith promises a delightful dining experience you won't forget!

A photo of Regina La Pizzeria restaurant

2. Regina La Pizzeria

4.6

Exceptional(28)

$$$$

• Pizzeria • Redfern

Booked 17 times today

Welcome to Regina La Pizzeria, where mid-century Italian charm meets contemporary dining in the heart of Redfern’s Wunderlich Lane.Founded by passionate restaurateurs Matteo Ernandes and Michela Boncagni, Regina blends authentic Italian cuisine with warm hospitality, offering a stylish yet welcoming atmosphere.At the core of our kitchen is Australia’s first Fazzone oven, crafted in Naples, Italy, and known for its ability to create pizzas with the perfect balance of a crispy crust and tender interior.Matteo, alongside two of Sydney’s finest chefs, Federico Zanellato and Karl Firla, has designed a menu that celebrates quality, tradition, and creativity.On the floor, Michela ensures every guest feels at home, combining fun, approachable service with professionalism. Our beverage selection, curated by Michela, features distinctive Italian wines and innovative drinks to perfectly complement your meal.

A photo of Tutto Vero Randwick restaurant

3. Tutto Vero Randwick

4.8

Exceptional(62)

$$$$

• Pizzeria • Randwick

Booked 6 times today

Step into Sydney’s Eastern Suburbs and experience "All True" Italian dining. Tutto Vero brings the authentic taste of Naples to Randwick.Our philosophy, "Tutto Vero" (It’s all genuine), is reflected in every dish. Antonio Lupo, a trained pizzaiolo from Napoli, oversees our incredible menu, which features our standout, must-try pizza: the Tutto Bene. This is an unforgettable balance of flavours, featuring San Marzano tomato, spicy Calabrian Nduja, creamy fresh ricotta, and a drizzle of Australian honey.Enjoy the warm, cozy atmosphere with friendly service that feels like dining at Nonna's house. Our focus is on relaxed, casual dining—come as you are and enjoy the simple pleasures of great Italian food.A neighbourhood gem, just minutes from the vibrant The Spot precinct, Centennial Parklands, and Coogee Beach.We craft everything in-house daily—from our signature pizzas, often lauded as the best in Sydney, to our homemade pastas and perfect Ricotta Cannoli.

4. Verace Pizzeria

4.6

Exceptional(1319)

$$$$

• Pizzeria • Macquarie Park

Booked 21 times today

Verace Pizzeria, nestled in the heart of Macquarie Park, has made an impressive mark on the dessert scene with its award-winning dessert pizzas. Having clinched the 1st Place Dessert Pizza at the 2018 World Pizza Championships, it's no surprise that their sweet offerings are considered "extremely good" and "amazing." Diners rave about the authenticity and quality of their desserts, often highlighting the "perfectly balanced flavors" that make each bite a delight. The "real cooked cream texture" of their panna cotta is another crowd favorite, adding to the allure of their exceptional dessert menu. Verace Pizzeria promises an unforgettable dessert experience with every visit.

A photo of Bill & Toni Italian Restaurant restaurant

5. Bill & Toni Italian Restaurant

4.4

Awesome(111)

$$$$

• Pizzeria • Darlinghurst

Booked 20 times today

Bill & Toni Italian Restaurant in Darlinghurst is a hidden gem for authentic Pizzeria cuisine, serving up a delightful slice of Italy since 1965. With its "divine and fresh" food, the restaurant has captured the hearts of many with its classic Italian offerings. Patrons rave about the "simple and fresh" dishes that transport them to "Little Italy," making it a must-visit destination for pizza enthusiasts. The welcoming atmosphere and "amazing" staff create an inviting space for families and friends alike. With a storied history and commitment to quality, Bill & Toni's promises an unforgettable dining experience that keeps guests coming back for more.

A photo of Barbara's Italian Restaurant restaurant

6. Barbara's Italian Restaurant

4.9

Exceptional(15)

$$$$

• Pizzeria • Kellyville

Booked 5 times today

Barbara’s Italian Restaurant & Bar is proudly family-run and operated by the young and hardworking couple, Zaman & Gigi.With decades of experience from leading hospitality groups and a genuine passion for food and beverages, we are dedicated to delivering an exceptional dining experience. Our vision is to offer authentic Italian cuisine in a warm, welcoming setting — not just as a place to dine, but a place to gather, celebrate, and feel at home.For almost a decade, Barbara’s has been known for its heartfelt hospitality, generous portions, and comforting flavors. Every dish is carefully prepared using quality ingredients and attention to detail, designed to be enjoyed and shared with family and friends.More than just a restaurant, Barbara’s is about connection — bringing people together for celebrations, casual dinners, and special occasions. Our attentive service and inviting atmosphere ensure every visit is memorable.Come in, relax, and taste the difference.

A photo of Pocket Pizza Neutral Bay restaurant

7. Pocket Pizza Neutral Bay

4.7

Exceptional(31)

$$$$

• Pizzeria • Neutral Bay

Booked 22 times today

Pocket Pizza has landed and we couldn't be happier! If good times, world class ambience, alluring carbs and juicy wines are found in your happy place, then we're going to get along swimmingly. Oh, and did we mention Aperitivo Hour?! $10 Spritz, $10 Negroni's, $5 Antipasto Plates & $5 Birra Every week from 4pm - 5:30pm, Friday - Sunday.

8. Braci

4.7

Exceptional(150)

$$$$

• Pizzeria • Willoughby

Booked 10 times today

Braci Osteria + Pizzeria in Willoughby is a shining star in Pizzeria cuisine, celebrated for its authentic and innovative approach. Reviewers rave about its "hands down best pizza in Sydney," elevating the dining experience with creative dishes like the Killer Bees pizza and mouthwatering mushroom pizza. The restaurant's commitment to quality shines through in its delicious gluten-free options, ensuring every diner leaves satisfied. Guests appreciate the "attentive and friendly service" from the team led by host Toby, making each visit memorable. With its elegant simplicity and vibrant atmosphere, Braci is a must-visit for pizza lovers seeking a culinary adventure.

9. Pompei's

4.8

Exceptional(44)

$$$$

• Pizzeria • Bondi Beach

Booked 9 times today

Two very special but uniquely different places are the inspiration behind Pompei’s. The spectacular rustic beauty of Cortina perched high in the Alps of northern Italy underpins everything we do. And the eclectic cool chic of the world’s most famous beach shapes how we do it. Just as the dramatic vertical pale peaks of the Dolomites contrasts with the cosmopolitan marine landscapes of Bondi, our faith in traditional artisanal hand-crafting cooking contrasts with our creativity and innovation to produce delicately balanced healthy dishes. It’s our tradition in evolution, continuing our journey guided by fond memories of my mother’s Italian home cooking. They say there’s two sides to every story - so stay a while and hear ours. We might be from Cortina, but we’ve made this place our home. And both places define us. We’re Bondi made Italian.

10. La Panchina

4.6

Exceptional(10)

$$$$

• Pizzeria • Surry Hills

Booked 2 times today

Amazing Central Italian style pizza and artisan-made gelato - on the corner of Arthur Street and Phelps Lane Surry Hills - eat in, do take-away in the park opposite or order home delivery - you choose and we'll cook

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

J
Jeannie
Greater Boston •1 review
5.0
Dined on May 23, 2026
Amazingly tasty pizza and pasta, sat at counter and it was fun watching the pizza being made. Bustling popular spot for a good reason.
More info
Regina La Pizzeria$$$$• Pizzeria• Redfern
•
4.6
D
Dana
Sydney •2 reviews
5.0
Dined on May 22, 2026
Great service ! Great food ! Everyone working was amazing the food was amazing. We will be back. We appreciate what a gem this place is.
More info
Tutto Vero Randwick$$$$• Italian• Randwick
•
4.8
C
Chich
Sydney •4 reviews
5.0
Dined on May 16, 2026
Excellent service from the moment we walked in. The drink service was quick. The service dining in was excellent. The food did not dissapoint. This is one of our favorite resturants.
More info
Product of Italy Penrith$$$$• Italian• Penrith
•
4.8
M
Michele
Sydney •1 review
5.0
Dined on May 8, 2026
Fabulous Italian Restaurant. The service and quality is top notch. Superb 🌟
More info
Verace Pizzeria$$$$• Pizzeria• Macquarie Park
•
4.6
U
Una
Sydney •1 review
5.0
Dined on Apr 24, 2026
We decided to have a birthday dinner at Barbara’s again and it didn’t disappoint. The meals were absolutely delicious. We are pretty picky when it comes to Italian food because my husband grew up with it. So we know what authentic is. Barbara’s is the place and no wonder it is popular with the locals. The staff are very friendly and nothing was too much trouble. Thank you so much!
More info
Barbara's Italian Restaurant$$$$• Italian• Kellyville
•
4.9

Explore OpenTable

Neighborhood
Pizzeria Cuisine

Castlereagh

Potts Point
North Ryde
Dawes Point / Walsh Bay
Erskineville
West Pennant Hills
Brighton Le Sands
Surry Hills
Bondi Beach
Freshwater
Banksia
Lidcombe
Bondi Junction
Auburn
Haymarket
Point Piper
Moore Park
Killara
Concord
Kogarah
North Sydney