22 Best Sicilian Restaurants In Allendale, New Jersey

1. Pizzeria Mandara

4.8

Exceptional(672)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Wyckoff

Booked 16 times today

Pizzeria Mandara in Wyckoff is a gem for those seeking authentic Southern Italian cooking and New York-style pizza. Inspired by the rich culinary traditions of Positano, Italy, this restaurant offers a menu that delights every palate. "Best pizza in the county," one enthusiastic diner raves, perfectly capturing the essence of their delectable offerings. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it an ideal spot to enjoy a meal with family and friends. With consistently high praise for its "friendly and accommodating" service and "delicious food," Pizzeria Mandara promises an unforgettable dining experience that keeps patrons returning for more.

A photo of Rosario's Trattoria restaurant

2. Rosario's Trattoria

4.7

Exceptional(263)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Wyckoff

Booked 10 times today

Rosario's Trattoria in Wyckoff, Midland Park is a beacon of excellent American cuisine, delighting diners with "amazing food and great service" consistently. With over 28 years of experience, this local eatery has mastered the art of combining fresh, high-quality ingredients with authentic American flavors. Guests rave about their generous portions and "mouthwatering" dishes, each crafted with care and attention to detail. The welcoming atmosphere and attentive staff make every visit special, ensuring that patrons leave "never disappointed." Whether it's a family gathering or a casual dinner, Rosario's Trattoria promises a delightful American dining experience that keeps guests returning for more.

3. Bottagra

4.7

Exceptional(1476)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Hawthorne

Booked 20 times today

Nestled in Hawthorne's historic Degray house, Bottagra offers an exquisite Mediterranean dining experience that captures the authentic essence of the region. With Chef-Owners Robert Vicari and Carlo Carbonaro at the helm, this elegant restaurant brings together the vibrant flavors of northern and southern Italy. Diners rave about the "deliciously tasty and flavorful" dishes, highlighting their freshness and impeccable presentation. The ambiance is described as a "mountain retreat vibe, rustic but elegant," adding to the charm of the Tuscan villa-inspired setting. Bottagra consistently delivers "excellent food, service, and ambiance," making it a standout choice for Mediterranean cuisine lovers.

4. Forte Ristorante

4.8

Exceptional(259)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Hackensack

Booked 18 times today

Forte Ristorante in Hackensack is a gem for Cocktail Bar enthusiasts, offering an exceptional blend of lively ambiance and expertly crafted drinks. Diners rave about the "excellent mixed drinks," highlighting the bar's creativity and quality in every pour. Whether you're there for a refreshing cocktail after a meal or a vibrant night out, Forte's bar scene does not disappoint. The experience is further enriched by the upbeat atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for a girls' night out or a relaxed evening with friends. Forte Ristorante's Cocktail Bar is a must-visit for anyone craving top-notch drinks and a memorable experience.

A photo of Carmine's - 91st Street - NYC restaurant

5. Carmine's - 91st Street - NYC

4.5

Awesome(8630)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Upper West Side

Booked 94 times today

Carmine's - 91st Street in NYC is a beacon of Contemporary Italian excellence, offering an authentic dining experience reminiscent of "Sunday at Grandma's house." Located in the vibrant Upper West Side, this family-style restaurant serves up generous portions of Southern Italian classics that are perfect for sharing. Diners rave about the "fantastic food," with dishes like manicotti and bolognese being standout favorites. The welcoming atmosphere and "impeccable service" contribute to its charm, making every meal feel like a festive occasion. Whether you're celebrating a special event or enjoying a casual meal, Carmine's promises a "core memory experience" with every visit!

A photo of Donatella's Ristorante restaurant

6. Donatella's Ristorante

4.3

Awesome(1099)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Closter

Booked 11 times today

Donatella's Ristorante is located in Harrington Park, NJ.

7. Campofiore

4.1

Excellent(41)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Montclair

Booked 72 times today

Campofiore is a farm-to-table concept that brings the vibrant tastes of Italy straight to the table. Led by Chef Dan Drohan, Campofiore will feature house cured salumi, artisanal regional Italian cheese selection, seasonal local vegetables, salads and seafood antipasto, a pasta selection featuring both handmade and imported pastas, as well as entrees and shared Items made from locally sourced seafood and meats prepared with traditional Italian technique. Desserts made by Pastry Chef Kazmire Puntarovic will be gelato-focused along with other traditional regional Italian sweets. The beverage program, which features a full bar, showcases a dynamic wine list where every bottle listed is $45. Saluti!

8. The Highlawn

4.4

Awesome(1706)

$$$$

• Sicilian • West Orange

Booked 35 times today

The Highlawn, perched elegantly atop Eagle Rock Reservation in West Orange, NJ, offers an authentic Italian dining experience that is nothing short of extraordinary. Under the expert guidance of Culinary Director and Executive Chef William Prunty, the restaurant has become a beacon of Italian culinary excellence. Guests rave about the “fantastic” food, highlighting dishes like the perfectly cooked Bronzino and flavorful ribeye. The Highlawn not only serves exquisite meals but also offers breathtaking views of the NYC skyline, making each dining experience a visual and gastronomic delight. With accolades like OpenTable's Diners' Choice Awards, it remains a top choice for Italian cuisine enthusiasts.

A photo of Maggiano's - Hackensack restaurant

9. Maggiano's - Hackensack

4.6

Exceptional(2645)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Hackensack

Booked 28 times today

Maggiano's - Hackensack offers an extraordinary taste of American cuisine with its Italian-American flair, nestled in the chic Shops at Riverside Mall. Diners rave about its "excellent food" and "outstanding service," creating an inviting culinary experience that's both authentic and delightful. This vibrant spot is ideal for special occasions, as one guest shared their engagement and birthday delight, praising the attentive care from staff. With a menu inspired by traditional recipes, Maggiano's serves up generous portions and rich flavors that promise to satisfy any palate. Whether it's a casual lunch or a grand celebration, Maggiano's ensures a memorable dining experience.

10. Lido

4.7

Exceptional(2138)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Harlem

Booked 25 times today

Lido is a Harlem favorite nestled on Frederick Douglass Boulevard, just a few blocks from 125th Street and the historic Apollo Theater. Conveniently located near both Central Park and Morningside Park, Lido offers a welcoming stop for locals and visitors alike looking to enjoy a memorable meal in a vibrant, culture-rich area.Our menu showcases the best of Northern Italian cuisine, with dishes that are thoughtfully layered to be fresh, simple, and delicious. We prioritize organic, locally-sourced ingredients whenever possible, and all our poultry and meats come from farms that practice an ethical treatment of animals.The ambiance at Lido is modish yet relaxed, making it the perfect setting for everything from weekend brunch to a cozy dinner with friends. Speaking of brunch—our brunch menu has become a local favorite, drawing crowds from all over the city for our seasonal specialties and classic Italian-inspired twists.We look forward to welcoming you soon!

Best Sicilian Restaurants in Allendale, New Jersey

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

22 restaurants available nearby

1. Pizzeria Mandara

2. Rosario's Trattoria

3. Bottagra

4. Forte Ristorante

5. Carmine's - 91st Street - NYC

6. Donatella's Ristorante

7. Campofiore

8. The Highlawn

9. Maggiano's - Hackensack

10. Lido

Explore OpenTable