Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York State

Best Steak Restaurants in Shelter Island

Price
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility

66 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of M.J. Dowling's restaurant
1. M.J. Dowling's
4.7
Exceptional(303)
$$$$
• Steak • Sag Harbor
Booked 22 times today
MJ Dowling’s Steakhouse and Tavern in the heart of Sag Harbor offers an unforgettable Steakhouse dining experience that is both authentic and inviting. This family-owned gem is praised for its "marinated hanger steak cooked to perfection," making it a must-try for steak enthusiasts. The comfortable and "relaxing environment" complements the consistently excellent service and delicious food, ensuring every visit is memorable. Diners rave about the "fabulous beef sliders" and are delighted by the nightly specials that offer a taste of their diverse menu at incredible value. MJ Dowling’s truly stands out as a neighborhood favorite, perfect for any occasion.
A photo of The Palm East Hampton restaurant
2. The Palm East Hampton
4.6
Exceptional(1150)
$$$$
• Steak • East Hampton
Booked 23 times today
The Palm East Hampton, nestled inside the charming Huntting Inn, offers a seafood cuisine that truly delights the senses. Diners rave about the "amazing lobster" and "delicious fish," praising the restaurant for its exceptional quality and fresh flavors. Guests consistently highlight the "fantastic" service and welcoming atmosphere, noting that every visit is a memorable experience. The Palm's lobster dinner for two is particularly popular, offering "great food and great value" in a stunning setting. As a staple in East Hampton, The Palm's commitment to authentic and fresh seafood makes it a must-visit destination for seafood lovers.
A photo of La Goulue Sur Mer restaurant
3. La Goulue Sur Mer
4.6
Exceptional(142)
$$$$
• Steak • Southampton
Booked 67 times today
Opening Early 2026. Serving French Bistro classics, from onion soup to steak frites, oysters and caviar. Stylish setting and a sophisticated atmosphere.
A photo of Lucky's - East Hampton restaurant
4. Lucky's - East Hampton
4.7
Exceptional(86)
$$$$
• Steak • East Hampton
Booked 26 times today
Lucky's has been honoring the classic American steakhouse tradition since 2000. Founded in Montecito, California and with openings Malibu and Soho, Lucky's makes a much-anticipated move out east with the opening of Lucky's East Hampton. Formerly the beloved Cove Hollow Tavern, Lucky's East Hampton maintains the team and spirit of its predecessor. The location features a cozy bar within the dining room for a casual but elevated experience. The menu features west coast favorites such as ‘Gene’s Filet’ (filet mignon, fresh horseradish and red wine sauce), alongside East Coast exclusives, such as thick-cut cajun bacon. A robust wine program and table side martini service rounds out the experience.
A photo of Gigi’s Montauk restaurant
5. Gigi’s Montauk
4.6
Exceptional(224)
$$$$
• Steak • Montauk
Booked 79 times today
Since its founding in 1926, Gurney’s Montauk has been a beloved destination for Long Islanders, New Yorkers, and travelers from around the world seeking an iconic, year-round escape by the sea. In Summer 2025, Gurney’s proudly unveils its first-ever flagship restaurant: Gigi’s Montauk. Offering both indoor and outdoor seaside dining, Gigi’s will feature a refined menu of New-American Coastal Cuisine, celebrating the spirit of Montauk with fresh, seasonal ingredients and elevated waterfront hospitality.
A photo of Dattilo Fine Italian at Water’s Edge restaurant
6. Dattilo Fine Italian at Water’s Edge
4.1
Excellent(1027)
$$$$
• Steak • Westbrook
Booked 15 times today
Nestled on the picturesque grounds of the Water’s Edge Resort and Spa in Westbrook, Dattilo Fine Italian offers an authentic Mediterranean culinary journey that transports diners straight to the sun-drenched coasts of Italy. Guests rave about the "wonderful food and service" paired with "breathtaking views" of the ocean, making it a perfect spot for any occasion. The rich and authentic menu is complemented by an extensive global wine list, enhancing the vibrant Mediterranean flavors. Whether enjoying their renowned Sunday brunch or indulging in nightly specials, Dattilo Fine Italian promises a "spectacular" dining experience that leaves a lasting impression.
A photo of Michael Jordan's Steak House - Mohegan Sun restaurant
7. Michael Jordan's Steak House - Mohegan Sun
4.8
Exceptional(8239)
$$$$
• Steak • Uncasville
Booked 92 times today
Michael Jordan's Steak House at Mohegan Sun is a hidden gem for seafood lovers in Uncasville, Connecticut. Renowned for its exquisite seafood offerings, this restaurant consistently delivers dishes that "melt in your mouth" and are "second to none in the northeast." Diners rave about the succulent crab cakes and the perfectly prepared salmon, which are standout items on the menu. The seafood tower is another crowd favorite, described as "awesome" and leaving guests eager to return. With a commitment to fresh, high-quality ingredients, the seafood here is not just a meal, but an unforgettable culinary experience.
A photo of The Patio at 54 Main restaurant
8. The Patio at 54 Main
4.7
Exceptional(1216)
$$$$
• Steak • Hamptons
Booked 52 times today
The Patio at 54 Main is a delightful haven for Modern Tuscan cuisine enthusiasts in Westhampton Beach. This charming trattoria effortlessly combines upscale dining with a casual atmosphere, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The restaurant's dedication to authenticity is evident in its freshly made pastas and expertly grilled steaks and fish. Diners rave about the "unreal" spicy rigatoni and "perfection" of the homemade raviolis. The signature 40-ounce porterhouse for two is a must-try, consistently praised for its "incredible" flavor. With consistently excellent food and service, The Patio is truly a "gem in the town of Westhampton."
A photo of Delilah Montauk presented by Chase Sapphire Reserve® restaurant
9. Delilah Montauk presented by Chase Sapphire Reserve®
3.8
Excellent(2)
$$$$
• Steak • Montauk
Booked 4 times today
To view availability for this event, add your eligible Chase card to your OpenTable account. Delilah is headed back East for another Summer in the Hamptons. Delilah, presented by Chase Sapphire Reserve, brings its signature glamour to Reserve cardmembers across two unforgettable weekends of decadent dining, classic American-inspired dishes, chilled champagne, overflowing seafood towers, and surprise performances to top it all off. Join us July 23 - 25 and July 30 - August 1PRIX FIXE DINNERS:Thursdays (7/23 & 7/30)Dinner & a Show featuring a Surprise GuestFridays (7/24 & 7/31)Dinner & a Show featuring a Surprise GuestGUEST ENTRY W/ SPECIAL PERFORMANCES:Saturday (7/25) - A special performance by Nicole Scherzinger & The Delilah BandSaturday (8/1) – A special performance by T-Pain & The Delilah BandChase Sapphire Reserve®, J.P. Morgan Reserve® and Chase Sapphire Reserve for Business® cardmembers are eligible for this event.
A photo of Tweeds Restaurant & Buffalo Bar restaurant
10. Tweeds Restaurant & Buffalo Bar
4.7
Exceptional(453)
$$$$
• Steak • Riverhead
Booked 6 times today
Tweeds Restaurant & Buffalo Bar is a delightful gem in Riverhead, offering a genuine taste of American cuisine with a unique twist. Known for its exceptional bison specialties, "the bison filet mignon is outstanding," Tweeds elevates classic American dishes with rich, savory flavors. The restaurant also boasts the largest selection of local and national bourbons in the area, perfectly complementing the hearty menu. Guests rave about the impeccable service and "friendly, attentive staff," creating a warm, inviting atmosphere. With live music enhancing the dining experience, Tweeds is a must-visit for anyone seeking an authentic and memorable American dining adventure.
‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
  • MARIEGold
    New York City •149 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 3 days ago
    Perfect way to spend a summer evening. Dinner outdoors in a lovely garden patio is very special. Appetizers are an excellent start to outstanding entrees. The traditional cheese soufflé is worth the wait. Fresh oyster special was a special that night- a dozen are a bargain. Hamburgers are comfort food in July. Take the time to enjoy dinner done very well. Service is attentive and friendly.
    More info
    La Goulue Sur Mer$$$$• French• Southampton
    •
    4.6
  • TheresaGold
    San Francisco Bay Area •7 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 7 days ago
    consistently great food and friendly polite service. always a good meal
    More info
    M.J. Dowling's$$$$• American• Sag Harbor
    •
    4.7
  • Michael
    Austin •1 review
    5.0
    Dined on Jul 3, 2026
    Great food. Great service. Great space and company
    More info
    The Palm East Hampton$$$$• Steakhouse• East Hampton
    •
    4.6
  • JonathanGold
    New York City •3 reviews
    5.0
    Dined on Jul 1, 2026
    10/10/10 food/service/vibe. Sat at the bar, party of three, great experience
    More info
    Lucky's - East Hampton$$$$• Steakhouse• East Hampton
    •
    4.7
  • BlairGold
    Greater Boston •6 reviews
    5.0
    Dined on Jul 1, 2026
    Gigi's was the perfect place to enjoy a meal with some of the best views in Montauk. The oceanfront setting is absolutely stunning, creating a relaxed yet upscale atmosphere that's hard to beat. The food was fresh, beautifully prepared, and full of flavor, while the cocktails were equally excellent. The service was attentive, welcoming, and made the entire experience feel special from start to finish. Whether you're visiting Gurney's or just looking for an unforgettable waterfront dining experience, Gigi's is well worth the visit. It's a place I'll gladly return to every time I'm back in Montauk.
    More info
    Gigi’s Montauk$$$$• American• Montauk
    •
    4.6

Explore OpenTable

Discover
OpenTable
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Press
More
Our sites
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2026 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 500, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo