Best Neighborhood Gem Restaurants in Montauk

Price

$$
$$$
$$$$

Cuisine

AmericanItalianSeafoodFrenchMexicanJapanese

Regions

HartfordKentMiddlesexNew HavenNew LondonNewport County

Neighborhoods

BranfordBridgehamptonCalvertonCenter MorichesClintonEast Greenwich

Top Rated

CharmingDog-friendlyFancyGood for business mealsGood for groupsGood for special occasions

Dining Options

All dining options

Delivery only

Takeout only

Seating Options

BarCounterStandardHigh TopOutdoor

Accessibility

Wheelchair access

40 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

1. Noah's

4.5

Awesome(2309)

$$$$

• Tapas / Small Plates • Greenport

Booked 17 times today

noah's is known for its trademark seafood inspired small plates that places great emphasis on fresh, seasonal ingredients from the North Fork and East End of Long Island. Our menus change daily as they are created to reflect what’s in season from the local farmers, fishermen, artisans and wineries. *OUTDOOR DINING IS FIRST COME FIRST SERVE.*For parties of 5 or more. Please refer to our cancelation policy.*noah's has a private dining room for up to 50 seated guest. Please inquire about your next special event with us!

2. Vine Street Cafe

4.9

Exceptional(1997)

$$$$

• American • Shelter Island

Booked 31 times today

Vine Street Cafe is a beloved neighborhood gem. Its cozy, rustic vibe and delicious food, made from locally sourced ingredients, have earned it glowing reviews. The friendly staff and attentive service are frequently praised. As one reviewer put it, 'Vine Street Cafe has a warm and inviting atmosphere and the cuisine is outstanding!' Another said, 'This is a great restaurant!! Everything was top notch!' The restaurant's consistently high ratings make it a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike.

A photo of The Bistro at Ocean House restaurant

3. The Bistro at Ocean House

4.4

Awesome(1192)

$$$$

• Bistro • Westerly

Booked 34 times today

At Ocean House, our classic American Bistro menu invites guests and visitors to enjoy casual, seasonally inspired dishes. Available for breakfast, lunch and dinner in The Bistro, Bar and Lounge. The Bistro menu offers traditional brasserie fare with a New England flavor. Begin your morning with inspired breakfast classics, fresh pastries or a colorful spread inspired by the season’s bounty. For lunch and dinner, a selection of starters and entrees are simply prepared and presented, with an emphasis on fresh local meats and sustainable seafood.SEATING: Your comfort is important to us. While we can’t promise a specific table, we’ll make every effort to meet your request.Cancellations within 24 hours and no-shows are subject to a $5 per person cancellation fee.

4. Elaia Estiatorio

4.8

Exceptional(395)

$$$$

• Greek • Bridgehampton

Booked 29 times today

ELAIA | (el-ah'-yah) | ἐλαία, ας, ἡ | Olive TreeYiassou, and Welcome Home. This Is Elaia, the Olive Tree, the foundation from which we create. Here we invite you to dine with us and relax into the Greek way of living. Our food is uncomplicated, healthy, and pairs beautifully with our selection of Greek wines. Please come and experience the fruits of the Olive Tree as we do – with Love, Hospitality, and Gratitude for all it provides.

5. The Bell & Anchor

4.9

Exceptional(599)

$$$$

• Seafood • Sag Harbor

Booked 19 times today

In 2012, The Bell & Anchor opened for its first summer. Now, open for much more and much longer than just summer: the waterside Sag Harbor restaurant conceived and operated by David Loewenberg & Sam McCleland stands firmly along side its sister restaurant, the Beacon. At The Bell & Anchor, you'll experience food and wine with deep flavors and textures. The restaurant pulls its inspiration from the rich & deep history Sag Harbor, Noyac, Peconic & the region offer: local seafood, steak, beer, vegetables, and wine. Enjoy!We offer reservations online for our dining room, bar, and patio. Reservations can be made up to two weeks in advance.

A photo of The Coast Guard House restaurant

6. The Coast Guard House

4.8

Exceptional(7949)

$$$$

• Seafood • Narragansett

Booked 101 times today

Dining in the main level dining room at the Coat Guard House in Narragansett is truly a special experience. The restaurant, hosed in a historic former life-saving station, offers breathtaking ocean views that guests consistently praise. The ambiance is warn and welcoming, with polished service that enhances the overall dining experience. We are happy offer our guests first come first serve complimentary valet.

7. 22 Bowen's

4.8

Exceptional(8267)

$$$$

• Wine Bar • Newport

Booked 135 times today

Prime Steaks and New England's finest seafood on historic Bowen's Wharf in Newport

A photo of Bridgehampton Inn Restaurant restaurant

8. Bridgehampton Inn Restaurant

4.7

Exceptional(699)

$$$$

• French American • Bridgehampton

Booked 10 times today

The primary and private dining rooms are located in the original first floor gathering spaces. The intimate restaurant deftly juxtaposes modern orange vinyl chairs with black and white portraits of Bridgehampton’s agrarian history, handblown glassware with delicate seasonal flowers. Featuring one-on-one service, the restaurant cozily seats 50 while offering a more relaxed atmosphere in the warm months on our private patio, which has been reconfigured to capture the beauty and peacefulness of our Inn’s garden. Our thoughtfully playful dinner menus change bi-weekly, with the season, and feature the best available, locally-gathered ingredients. That means 800+ recipes a year - how exciting! Each week: the menu consistently serves a form of duck and fish, an iteration of the fritter - lobster, artichoke, zucchini - and our all-time favorite cheeses found at Loaves & Fishes Food Store on cheese stones.

A photo of Standards Jamestown restaurant

9. Standards Jamestown

4.7

Exceptional(159)

$$$$

• American • Jamestown

Booked 14 times today

Standards is a home-style restaurant serving family favorites made from traditional recipes, with a choice selection of draft beers wines, and signature cocktails. Whether you're craving hearty classics or a uniquedrink, Standards Jamestown brings the warmth of home to every meal.

A photo of Comomango Mexican Kitchen and Cantina restaurant

10. Comomango Mexican Kitchen and Cantina

4.6

Exceptional(152)

$$$$

• Mexican • Madison

Booked 19 times today

Experience upscale Mexican cuisine with a delightful twist at Comomango Mexican Kitchen and Cantina. Our newly redesigned downtown spot offers a charming ambiance, perfect for enjoying drinks and appetizers at the bar or dining on our enclosed porch year-round. Indulge in our inventive tacos with homemade tortillas, featuring flavors like savory shrimp or succulent pulled pork tamales. Cap off your meal with our creamy Tres Leches dessert. With prompt service and engaged waitstaff, every visit is a celebration of flavor and hospitality.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

D
DebbieGold
Northwest Florida •9 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
Great view and wonderful service highly recommend the bistro
More info
The Bistro at Ocean House$$$$• Bistro• Westerly
•
4.4
M
michele
New York City •13 reviews
5.0
Dined 5 days ago
Everything about my visit was great. The wait staff was very attentive and friendly. The food was outstanding! Will be back for sure.
More info
Noah's$$$$• Tapas / Small Plates• Greenport
•
4.5
B
Beate
1 review
5.0
Dined 6 days ago
Vine Street is our favorite. Thank you for always accommodating and placing us in the front room. We shall be back soon. Food, service, everything is perfection. THANK YOU!!
More info
Vine Street Cafe$$$$• American• Shelter Island
•
4.9
W
Wendi
New York City •8 reviews
5.0
Dined on May 23, 2026
I've been coming here for years. It's been one of my favorites for all the years I've been out here. I say it's a hidden gem, but I don't think it's so hidden anymore. The place is always bustling and crowded. Whoever we take for dinner there always agrees it's one of the best restaurants out in the Hamptons. The food is always delicious and has interesting flavors. My go to to impress friends or just to have a nice meal with my husband at the bar
More info
The Bell & Anchor$$$$• Seafood• Sag Harbor
•
4.9
K
Kimberly
New York City •28 reviews
5.0
Dined on May 22, 2026
One the the best in the Hamptons! Delicious and fun!
More info
Elaia Estiatorio$$$$• Greek• Bridgehampton
•
4.8

Explore OpenTable

Neighborhood
Neighborhood gem

Montauk

South Salem
Williston Park
Sayville
Valhalla
Southampton
West Sayville
Sag Harbor
Rye
Dobbs Ferry
Stormville
Port Chester
New Rochelle
Smithtown
Amagansett
Westhampton Beach
Glen Head
Seaford
East Islip
Monroe
Yonkers