Hal's - Buckhead
I had an 8pm reservation. We didn’t get seated till 8:30. Best that wasn’t Hal’s fault. The hostess explained that 7 tables had paid their tabs, but had not left. And half way through my meal, I understood why! Great food and great service!
It was a pretty interesting evening. The waiter was excellent and so was the food. However, we were sitting in a table that was right by the bar so I felt a little awkward. Like I was sitting in a hallway or something. However, I ordered the bone-in filet and it was delicious.
Every thing was great at the restaurant, but I gave it a 3
due to the extra $75 dollars I had to pay when a boot was put on my car tire
It was dark when we arrived and I missed the posted signs in the parking lot
ajoinimg the restaurant.
Open table or Hal's should notify people that this can and will happen
When it does, I will give it a Yes rating
Went Day after Valentines and ate in main level.
It was way too crowded and the tables were too close. All those extra tables-not a good idea. Ruined our experience. Near by customers were also complaining
Great food, great service, will definitely return!
I guess in an attempt to serve as many people as possible more tables had been added since our last time there. The tables are to close together, which limits the personal space and dining. This also made the noise level higher. The tables are so close together even the servers had trouble getting by and delivering food.
Great Valentine’s Day Date. We arrived 10 min after our scheduled reservation, we checked in and were at our cozy table in less than 5 min.
Best steak I have ever eaten!
Excellent steak on Valentine’s Day
Valentine's dinner was a huge mistake at Hal's. They brought in a whole room full of 2 top tables. The room was crowded and noisy. Seating was so tight the waiters kept bumping into us. We will.probably never go back to Hal's.
Went to Hals for V-Day. Food and wine were great. Waiter was very helpful and attentive even on a busy night. The person who greeted us when we walked in was not very welcoming. This seems to be a common issue as I read other reviews and I guess Hals does not seem interested in dealing with this issue. Although people were smoking at the bar, the air quality was fine. Would definitely go back
Great food great service.
Awesome! Outstanding! Loved it!! Always the best!!
Great food and service!
This place never disappoints! My guest s were pleased. The food was great, my drinks were superb. I love this place!
Always a great meal and always full!
Excellent place to enjoy a good steak. Great ambiance. Would go back
I love it! The piano player/singer was awesome! The steak was amazing!!!!
Great food and nice place as.long as you sit upstairs away from smokey bar downstairs. Tables are very close together. Food and service was top notch!! Wine prices are a good value as well.
My friends arrived on time & I was a few minutes late. We had a great time with good food & an attentive waiter!
Everything was great. Steaks took a long time but waiter acknowledged and gave us dessert on the house.
Filet is top notch.
Seating is a bit tight and noisy to have any business conversation.
Waited 30 minutes to sit after our reservation. Food took almost 45 minutes to come out.
You can never go wrong with the Quality of Food and service at Hal's always a pleasure. Our server Jeff was amazing... The food came out on time, hot and tasty... Love Hal's
I have been going there for over 20 years. They are constantly great from the staff to the food and the environment is second to none. You will not fine a better steak anywhere in Atlanta and their lamb chops are the best. The cost is wonderful for what you get. You may think 56.00 for a bone in filet is high but when you bite into it you will say that is worth every penny and it is. There is only 4 in a cow.
We had a wonderful birthday at Hal’s on Saturday! Our server Jeff was amazing as always!
Food,service and atmosphere were all exceptional! My family had never been, and they were not disappointed!
Perfectly cooked steak every time. Great sides, salads and appetizers too. And great seafood. Lively atmosphere and great music on weekends.
Was a great evening but the noise from the bar area was just too loud. We were seated on the first floor in front of the curtain to an employee space. There were lots of servers passing by our table all night.
The restaurant value and ambiance is severely diminished by the ever-present cigarette and cigar smoke from the Bar.
Don’t like you can smoke. I ate in bar and it got quite smoky.
This was my first time to Hal’s. I eat at a lot of nice steak houses in my travels. This place is a gem I’m so many aspects. Amazing staff (Scott was our waiter) amazing atmosphere. It’s old, it’s young, it’s classy it’s laid back it is everything I want in a steakhouse.
One thing people need to know (and for me this adds to the greatness) people can smoke inside, the ventilation was great and you don’t really smell anything in the dinner areas. Just amazing I will be back every time I’m in Atlanta. PS . I rarely leave reviews. I felt compelled to leave one for this amazing spot!!
We were here for the Super Bowl .. heard nothing but good things about the place ... Hands down one of the best restaurants we have even been to and Shawn our Server was amazing! Deserves 10 stars all day!
Everything was fantastic. The waiter was very professional with a great attitude. My son and I were in for the Super Bowl. It’s just as good as the NY Steakhouses.
Always great food and exceptionally good service.
Fabulous anniversary dinner. The food was excellent and service was perfect.
I go to Hal’s regularly. We were not seated until nearly 10:00 for a 8:45 reservation. We were hosting out of town guests and one of them was diabetic which made it uncomfortable for us as they didn’t want to complain to me as the host....but they were not happy.
Fabulous and Delicious!!!
Super bowl loud. Really fun. Food was great. Probably didn’t need the music as it was hard to hear