Diners' Choice: Pizzeria restaurants in New York City

OpenTable

Updated September 05, 2024

Looking for restaurants with the best overall Pizzeria cuisine in New York City? You’re in the right place. Each month OpenTable analyzes more than 400,000 new diner reviews. We sort the results by category to help you discover new favorites. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Tottenville

4.9

4.9 (33)

$31 to $50

Pizzeria

Tottenville

About the restaurant

Specializing in authentic coal-fired Italian pizza, antipasto and other traditional Italian dishes. We use only the freshest and finest ingredients. We also make our own mozzarella daily by hand and have a full bar!

Top review

Dined on Aug 25, 2024

Pleasant experience. Food is good. Fast service ..

Song E Napule - West Village NYC

4.8

4.8 (101)

$30 and under

Pizzeria

Greenwich Village

About the restaurant

Song'E Napule has just opened this NEW location at 132 W Houston St, close to our first and classic spot at 146 W Houston St.

Top review

Hectorvip

Dined 3 days ago

Authentic Neapolitan pizza with an atmosphere that makes you feel like you're in Napoli. Loved it! H

Discover more

Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Dongan Hills

4.8

4.8 (85)

$31 to $50

Pizzeria

South Beach

About the restaurant

Top review

Michael

Dined on Aug 27, 2024

Absolutely wonderful experience celebrating my child's first day of school. Food and portion sizes were fantastic to go along with a great server and team serving us. Thank you.

Daddies

4.4

4.4 (16)

$31 to $50

Pizzeria

West Village

About the restaurant

New pizza and pasta spot by chef @frankprisinzano now in the West Village. Like the name, Daddies is plural, for everybody, grandparents, parents, kids, babies... Daddies is for all.

Come and enjoy our Neapolitan inspired pies and our amazing selection of fresh homemade pastas made daily.

Top review

Shay

Dined on Aug 13, 2024

Sooo good! The food, service and vibes. Highly recommend. Can’t wait to go back.

Song E Napule - UWS

4.7

4.7 (241)

$31 to $50

Pizzeria

Upper West Side

About the restaurant

We're serving the flavors and the feeling of an authentic Italian meal right to you! From traditional brick oven pizzas to homemade gnocchi to hearty pastas, every dish is made with care for our customers to savor. Visit us and settle in to absorb the sights, the scents and the sounds of our kitchen.

Top review

Manuelvip

Dined 3 days ago

Great italian food, amazing authentic Neapolitan style pizza in a cozy and elegant location

Discover more

San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina

4.8

4.8 (392)

$30 and under

Pizzeria

Upper East Side

About the restaurant

At San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina located in the Upper East Side of New York City, guests enjoy authentic Neapolitan pizzas, panuozzi and other Italian favorites. Panuozzi, which is made with charred pizza dough that is folded over and stuffed with tasty ingredients, is growing in popularity, especially in the New York City pizzeria scene. San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina has mastered this unique dish with its selection of panuozzi. Because San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina is open until 11 p.m., it is a suitable place for late-night meals with family or friends. Sip on a glass of red or white wine while partaking in popular menu items like the pancetta panuozzo, which features dry-cured pancetta, provolone cheese, black pepper and artichokes, and the Diavola pizza, which is topped with fresh basil, homemade mozzarella, spicy soppressata and parmigiano reggiano.

Top review

Adithya

Dined on Aug 17, 2024

great food and service. neopolitan pizza was excellent.

Discover more

4.7

4.7 (184)

$30 and under

Pizzeria

West Village

About the restaurant

A typical food love story. A boy meets a girl while eating pizza. He attends culinary school and open’s a pizza restaurant named after the girl. Thus bringing us to Emily! The Manhattan iteration of the Brooklyn based pizzeria centered around a historic brick oven and comforting food. Emily has earned a following for its signature Detroit-style pies and award winning burger. The pizza here is rectangular (not round) and utilizes the "frico" technique, in which cheese is drizzled on the edges of the pie to create a crispy brown exterior. Beyond the main event, the menu extends to include salads and sandwiches, which shouldn't be ignored (think an attention-grabbing burger and a top-notch spicy fried chicken sandwich).

Please note, there will be a time limit of 1 hour 30 minutes for guests so we can fairly utilize our limited capacity. Our outdoor dining is enclosed with heaters that will keep you toasty! Thank you :)

Top review

jamiewarfzvip

Dined on Aug 30, 2024

I love coming here. Emily has mine (and my guests) favorite burger in NYC, always. One of my friend’s is kosher and got an Emmy Burger without cheese, and I couldn’t believe how delicious it still was. Andrew is also THE BEST WAITER ON THE PLANET!! Coming back as soon as I possibly can…. :) I love you guys !

Discover more

Popular dish

Burger

Emmy Squared Pizza - Hell’s Kitchen

4.8

4.8 (63)

$30 and under

Pizzeria

Hell's Kitchen

About the restaurant

Offering quality ingredients and deliciously unique toppings, our signature Detroit-style pizza is marked by its square shape, crispy bottom, fluffy dough, cheesy "frico" crust, and signature sauce stripes. Our famed double-stack burger, the Le Big Matt, was named ‘#1 Best Burger in Nashville’ by The Tennessean and Nashville Lifestyles, voted one of ‘The Best New Burgers In NYC’ by Gothamist, and listed as one of the ‘20 Best Burgers in NYC’ by The Infatuation. The menu also highlights a selection of approachable salads and sandwiches served on pretzel buns.

Gaining critical claim and an ever-growing cult following, we have expanded the Emmy Squared brand with eight locations across New York City, Nashville, Philadelphia, Washington DC, and Louisville and plans to expand nationally. In every neighborhood we join, our team is committed to contributing to the community and practice our company ethos of inclusivity and unparalleled hospitality.

Top review

OpenTable Diner

Dined on Jul 23, 2024

Delish gluten free pizza and burgers! In the heart of Broadway!

Crosta

4.8

4.8 (91)

$30 and under

Pizzeria

Park Slope

About the restaurant

Pizzeria, a synonym for home, a soul place. The place where everything started. Where our life story exists and lives. Where ancient techniques and traditions are strictly adopted. Where the best food products we can get strengthen their flavors, aromas and colors of our dishes. Where when the working hours are over we gather around the table with the desire and happiness to share dinner. Where the pizzeria becomes a creativity lab so as to offer unique combinations of flawless quality and taste. Where everything is the result of a great team effort. Where we enjoy the pleasure of cooking for others and make them happy. Where Crosta comes to life!

Top review

JenniferR

Dined on Jun 15, 2024

This was our first time trying Christa, despite passing it frequently. We were very happy! The service was great, the food was really good (we tried the Italian wings, arancini, a pizza, and the Chrosta burger as well as some gelato), and the pricing was in line with the neighborhood. Outside seating on a beautiful evening was icing on the cake. Definitely recommend!

Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Bay Ridge

4.6

4.6 (83)

$31 to $50

Pizzeria

Bay Ridge

About the restaurant

Campania Coal Fired Pizza specializes in exactly what its name implies: delicious pizza cooked in a coal oven to produce a unique smoky texture to the crust and toppings. This special method of cooking pizza imparts certain flavors that simply can't be replicated by using a wood burning stove or other method of heating. Diners simply need to taste for themselves the difference Campania's incredibly hot coal-fired grill makes Campania's pizza menu comes with a build-your-own pizza option as well as several signature house recipes. Some of the delicious pizzas diners can try out are the Margherita, Buffalo Chicken and the Calabrese with tomato sauce, hot soppressata, mozzarella, pecorino romano and basil. If guests aren't in the mood for pizza they can also order one of the sandwiches like the chicken parmigiana or the Napoli with grilled chicken, mozzarella and a made-from-scratch pesto sauce.

Top review

Kathy

Dined on Aug 29, 2024

Neighborhood gem!!! Food was great, large portions, service excellent as always. Highly recommended. So happy to see that I can make reservations now too! A definite plus!!!

Explore Diners' Choice best of New York City

Explore more Diners' Choice lists