Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New Jersey

Best Italian Restaurants in Middletown, New Jersey

Price
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Award-winning
Accessibility

142 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Trattoria Toscana restaurant
1. Trattoria Toscana
4.1
Excellent(81)
$$$$
• Italian • Middletown
Booked 11 times today
Experience the Flavors of Tuscany at our Italian RestaurantExperience authentic Italian cuisine made with fresh ingredients accompanied by the best selection of wines. Our burger menu and wide array of meat choices transforms our Italian Restaurant into Italian steakhouse
A photo of Pazzo Restaurant restaurant
2. Pazzo Restaurant
4.6
Exceptional(4871)
$$$$
• Italian • Red Bank
Booked 44 times today
Pazzo is an Italian restaurant in Red Bank serving a variety of traditional menu items, along with several unique family recipes and other creative fare. Our Italian cuisine is made with the freshest ingredients from local farms and importers direct from Italy. Wines, craft beers and exclusive cocktails are paired with our dishes to enhance your dining experience. We also offer Gluten Free pizzas and pastas!
A photo of Il Colosseo - New Jersey restaurant
3. Il Colosseo - New Jersey
4.8
Exceptional(1043)
$$$$
• Italian • Red Bank
Booked 16 times today
Il Colosseo in Red Bank, NJ, is a seafood lover's paradise, offering a delightful array of authentic Italian seafood dishes. Diners rave about their "spectacular" Seafood Salad, which sets the tone for a memorable meal. The Black Ravioli with Seafood is another standout, praised for its delicious flavors and perfect execution. The Scottish salmon dish, "perfectly cooked with a tasteful mango sauce," has received particular kudos from regulars. With impeccable service and a welcoming atmosphere, Il Colosseo ensures every visit is a culinary delight. Experience the exceptional seafood cuisine that keeps patrons returning again and again to this beloved establishment.
A photo of Falcone restaurant
4. Falcone
4.8
Exceptional(518)
$$$$
• Italian • Middletown
Booked 20 times today
BYOB.
A photo of Semolina Restaurant restaurant
5. Semolina Restaurant
4.6
Exceptional(3520)
$$$$
• Italian • Red Bank
Booked 29 times today
Semolina Restaurant in Red Bank is a gem of Contemporary Italian cuisine, praised for its inventive use of local, fresh ingredients that elevate traditional Italian dishes to new heights. The farm-to-table approach ensures every dish bursts with flavor and authenticity, with "pasta dishes that are particularly fantastic," as diners rave. Guests highlight the "outstanding" service and the cozy, welcoming BYO atmosphere that complements the dining experience. The menu, which rotates seasonally, keeps patrons excited with each visit. Semolina's commitment to quality and creativity makes it a standout choice for anyone eager to indulge in exceptional Contemporary Italian dining.
A photo of Buona Sera restaurant
6. Buona Sera
4.7
Exceptional(1998)
$$$$
• Italian • Red Bank
Booked 46 times today
(Online reservations for 5 or more, please call us)** 2 hour min required for Pre Count Basie show reservations. The classy and elegant Buona Sera is located in Red Bank area of New Jersey. The dining room is gorgeous with carefully planned details and decorations that add a sense of refinement to the restaurant. You can also host an event or party in the Wine Cellar or Tuscan Room. Catering services can be ordered for in-house reservations as well as for outside events. Buona Sera is a full service bar and restaurant, and our menu is quite extensive, giving you a lot of lunch and dinner options to choose from. Start off with one of the large and flavorful appetizers, then continue to the main course. Entrées at Buona Sera include pasta, veal, choice steaks, chicken, pork chops, various types of ravioli and seafood. Veal chops from this restaurant are some of the most popular dishes on the menu and are worth trying.
A photo of The Bistro at Red Bank restaurant
7. The Bistro at Red Bank
4.8
Exceptional(832)
$$$$
• Italian • Red Bank
Booked 31 times today
The Bistro at Red Bank is a shining star in the realm of Global, International cuisine, nestled in the heart of downtown Red Bank. This beloved BYO restaurant has been delighting patrons since 1996 with its eclectic menu that truly offers "something for everyone." From innovative sushi creations to homemade pastas and brick-oven pizzas, each dish showcases a commitment to market-fresh ingredients and authentic flavors. Diners rave about the "amazing top-of-the-line service" and "incredible food," making it a must-visit for both locals and visitors alike. With its vibrant atmosphere and consistently outstanding culinary offerings, The Bistro at Red Bank promises an unforgettable dining experience.
A photo of Assaggini di Roma - Hazlet restaurant
8. Assaggini di Roma - Hazlet
4.8
Exceptional(642)
$$$$
• Italian • Hazlet
Booked 3 times today
Located in Hazlet NJ. Serving fresh Italian favorites with our own signature dishes. Make a reservation today to try the best Italian in the area!
A photo of Monticello at Red Bank restaurant
9. Monticello at Red Bank
4.6
Exceptional(1773)
$$$$
• Italian • Red Bank
Booked 6 times today
Monticello at Red Bank is a beacon of authentic Mediterranean cuisine, setting a high standard with its commitment to fresh, non-GMO, and hormone-free ingredients. Diners rave about the "outstanding" flavors and "exceptionally fresh" dishes, often highlighting the unique garden-to-table experience from their onsite organic garden. Located in the heart of Red Bank, the restaurant offers an intimate and romantic ambiance, perfect for any occasion. The chef's philosophy of clean, Mediterranean eating is evident in every meticulously prepared dish, from the sumptuous seafood spaghettini to the exquisite poached pear salad. As one reviewer exclaims, "Every meal is a great meal from start to finish!"
A photo of Elli’s Backyard restaurant
10. Elli’s Backyard
4.5
Awesome(512)
$$$$
• Italian • Red Bank
Booked 8 times today
Elli’s Backyard in Red Bank, NJ, is a dessert lover's paradise, offering an authentic taste experience that keeps diners coming back for more. Known for its “decadent flourless chocolate cake” and innovative “ice-cream soft choc chip cookie combo,” aptly named "the bomb," Elli's desserts are a highlight not to be missed. The restaurant's attention to detail and commitment to quality shine through in every sweet treat, providing delightful endings to their already impressive meals. The charming, backyard ambiance adds to the overall experience, making it a perfect spot for dessert enthusiasts seeking something truly special in Red Bank.
‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
  • Sarah
    New York City •14 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 3 days ago
    Had a great first experience here. Both the food and service were fantastic! Devin was our server and he was friendly, informative, and made the experience even better. All the food was fresh and flavorful. The crudo was a 10/10. Their desserts also were amazing, highly recommend the olive oil cake and rice pudding. We will be back to see Devin again! A great BYOB spot in the area.
    More info
    Semolina Restaurant$$$$• Farm-to-table• Red Bank
    •
    4.6
  • joan
    New York City •14 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 4 days ago
    First time visiting Falcone and loved the ambiance. What a surprise to walk into such a beautiful room! Our server was fun and engaging and the food superb. That was one of the best halibut dishes I've ever had and I'm already planning another visit. Thank you for a wonderful evening!
    More info
    Falcone$$$$• Italian• Middletown
    •
    4.8
  • Charles
    New York City •8 reviews
    5.0
    Dined on May 23, 2026
    All good. Never have a bad meal here. Will be back.
    More info
    Pazzo Restaurant$$$$• Italian• Red Bank
    •
    4.6
  • Gerry
    New York City •26 reviews
    5.0
    Dined on May 17, 2026
    We had a 2PM reservation on Sunday and everything was great. Service is top notch and the servers are all seasoned pros. Food was delicious! George is the best!
    More info
    Il Colosseo - New Jersey$$$$• Italian• Red Bank
    •
    4.8
  • Barbara
    Greater Boston •4 reviews
    5.0
    Dined on Apr 25, 2026
    We were visiting the area for a family event and decided to stay overnight in Middletown. We found this restaurant and loved the menu that we saw and the reviews. We are so glad that we went. The food was wonderful and service excellent and wait staff very attentive. The hostesses were two very sweet young ladies also. We were more impressed when we heard the entertainment. It was so nice to have some nice music during dinner. Although we don’t live in the area we would definitely go back if we were in Middletown again. Thank you for a lovely evening!!!
    More info
    Trattoria Toscana$$$$• Italian• Middletown
    •
    4.1

Explore OpenTable

Discover
OpenTable
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Press
More
Our sites
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2026 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 500, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo