229 Best Southern American Restaurants In Shelter Island

1. Vine Street Cafe

4.8

Exceptional(2016)

$$$$

• Southern american • Shelter Island

Booked 69 times today

Vine Street Cafe on Shelter Island offers an exquisite Fusion/Eclectic dining experience that consistently delights both locals and visitors alike. Chef Terry Harwood's commitment to utilizing the freshest local produce, seafood, and wines is evident in every seasonal menu, which boasts memorable dishes like the calamari salad and spicy tuna tacos. Diners rave about the "consistently outstanding" meals and the "wonderful ambiance" that complement the creative culinary offerings. This charming eatery's dedication to quality and authenticity shines through, making it "the best of the best" on the island. Whether celebrating a special occasion or enjoying a casual meal, Vine Street Cafe promises a delightful fusion feast.

A photo of The Terrace at the Pridwin restaurant

2. The Terrace at the Pridwin

4.5

Awesome(271)

$$$$

• Southern american • Shelter Island

Booked 60 times today

The Terrace at the Pridwin is a seafood lover's paradise nestled on Shelter Island, offering a dining experience that is both exquisite and authentic. The restaurant's commitment to quality is evident in its use of fresh, locally sourced ingredients, ensuring that each dish bursts with flavor. Diners can revel in “the best linguine with clam sauce ever” and delight in the perfectly crispy Fritto Misto. The lobster roll, served on a homemade brioche bun, is a standout, described as a “buttery compliment to the lobster.” With its breathtaking views over Crescent Beach and impeccable service, The Terrace promises an unforgettable seafood dining adventure.

3. Noah's

4.6

Exceptional(2328)

$$$$

• Southern american • Greenport

Booked 18 times today

Noah's in Greenport is a seafood lover's paradise, celebrated for its fresh, authentic dishes that highlight the bounty of Long Island's North Fork and East End. Diners rave about the "perfectly curated and executed" menu, which changes daily to feature the freshest local catch and seasonal ingredients. Standout dishes like the "best NE Clam Chowder," "crab cakes pure crab with no bread fillers," and "fantastic clam pasta" showcase the restaurant's commitment to quality. Guests are consistently impressed with the "outstanding service" and the inviting ambiance that makes every visit to Noah's an unforgettable experience. It's no wonder Noah's is a beloved destination for both locals and visitors alike.

A photo of SALT Shelter Island restaurant

4. SALT Shelter Island

new

4.6

Exceptional(207)

$$$$

• Southern american • Shelter Island

Booked 36 times today

The story of SALT started with Keith and Ali's love for Shelter Island. SALT was designed as a come as you are restaurant with a focus on fresh and local foods, that anyone can enjoy. They wanted to create a place they would want to go for dinner or drinks and find friendly service from other people who live and love Shelter Island. We treat locals like celebrities and celebrities like locals!

A photo of The North Fork Table & Inn restaurant

5. The North Fork Table & Inn

4.8

Exceptional(2506)

$$$$

• Southern american • Southold

Booked 36 times today

North Fork Table is an East End institution. Set in a historic countryside home, the restaurant celebrates the bounty of Long Island’s farms, vineyards & waterways with menus by restaurateur & chef John Fraser. The restaurant’s menu focus is seasonally inspired featuring locally grown biodynamic and organic produce, the freshest seafood from the pristine Peconic Bay and Long Island Sound and award-winning North Fork duck and beef. Increasingly distinguished and awarded Long Island wines are highlighted on the wine list, as well as their national and international counterparts.

A photo of The Halyard Restaurant at Sound View restaurant

6. The Halyard Restaurant at Sound View

4.5

Awesome(1763)

$$$$

• Southern american • Greenport

Booked 47 times today

The Halyard Restaurant at Sound View in Greenport offers an unparalleled seafood experience that captures the essence of Long Island’s North Fork. Renowned for its fresh, local ingredients, diners rave about the "divine scallops" and the "delicious and interesting" tuna tartare, which showcase the authentic flavors of the sea. The restaurant's commitment to quality is evident in every dish, earning glowing reviews for both its culinary excellence and breathtaking views of the Long Island Sound. Whether enjoying the "amazing sunset" or savoring the perfectly prepared mussels and crab cakes, guests are guaranteed a memorable dining experience at The Halyard.

7. Anker

4.4

Awesome(24)

$$$$

• Southern american • Greenport

Booked 6 times today

We are a local, seasonal American seafood restaurant and market located in the heart of Greenport, NY, highlighting the best of North Fork farms and fisheries. Our menu reflects the day's catch and weekly harvest - light, bright, clean flavors - meant to complement the beautiful views of the Peconic Bay on our upstairs covered deck. On the beverage side, guests can expect a mix of classic and seasonal cocktails, craft beers and thoughtfully-selected wines. Offering one of the finest harbor views in Greenport from our second floor patio, the restaurant's design is intended to carry guests away. We hope to welcome you for lunch or dinner soon!

8. Sophie's Rest.

4.5

Awesome(100)

$$$$

• Southern american • Southold

We refuse to compromise on quality in our restaurant. That's why we source our fresh ingredients from local farms and fish markets. Everything from in house hand cut steaks to our daily "catch of the day." No matter what time of year, you can be sure you're eating the best of the season.Special Nights: Prime Rib Tuesday Includes: Caesar salad- Generous cut of Prime Rib with chef's choice potato and vegetable $39Please call in advance during business hours (by the Monday night before) for Prime Rib Tuesday reservations at 631-765-5700As we enter the summer months, a reminder that even though we have outdoor dining, our restaurant is not dog friendly. We only allow service dogs with proper collars/identification. If this is not the case, please leave your furry friend at home!

9. Beacon Sag Harbor

4.8

Exceptional(51)

$$$$

• Southern american • Sag Harbor

Booked 63 times today

Perched above the Sag Harbor Cove Yacht Club, The Beacon offers one of the East End's most stunning waterfront views — sweeping across Sag Harbor Bay all the way to Shelter Island. It's the quintessential Hamptons sunset, best enjoyed from our expansive upstairs porch with a cocktail in hand. A seasonal restaurant open through the warmer months, we've been serving dinner on the harbor since 1999.The menu draws on American, Mediterranean, and Asian influences, with signature dishes like steamed mussels, pork belly buns, and baked halibut, plus homemade desserts worth saving room for.Owners David Loewenberg and Sam McCleland met on the Hamptons restaurant scene in the 1990s and have been partners ever since. In 2012, they opened The Bell & Anchor, extending The Beacon's hospitality into the off-season.Casually upscale and warmly inviting — the perfect spot for a summer evening on the water.

10. The Bell & Anchor

4.9

Exceptional(636)

$$$$

• Southern american • Sag Harbor

Booked 58 times today

In 2012, The Bell & Anchor opened for its first summer. Now, open for much more and much longer than just summer: the waterside Sag Harbor restaurant conceived and operated by David Loewenberg & Sam McCleland stands firmly along side its sister restaurant, the Beacon. At The Bell & Anchor, you'll experience food and wine with deep flavors and textures. The restaurant pulls its inspiration from the rich & deep history Sag Harbor, Noyac, Peconic & the region offer: local seafood, steak, beer, vegetables, and wine. Enjoy!We offer reservations online for our dining room, bar, and patio. Reservations can be made up to two weeks in advance.

Best Southern American Restaurants in Shelter Island

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

229 restaurants available nearby

1. Vine Street Cafe

2. The Terrace at the Pridwin

3. Noah's

4. SALT Shelter Island

5. The North Fork Table & Inn

6. The Halyard Restaurant at Sound View

7. Anker

8. Sophie's Rest.

9. Beacon Sag Harbor

10. The Bell & Anchor

Explore OpenTable