Diners' Choice: Italian restaurants in Peninsula

OpenTable

Updated May 05, 2026

Looking for restaurants with the best overall Italian cuisine in Peninsula? You’re in the right place. Each month OpenTable analyzes more than 400,000 new diner reviews. We sort the results by category to help you discover new favorites. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

888 Ristorante Italiano

5.0

5 (711)

$30 and under

Italian

San Carlos

About the restaurant

If you’ve ever enjoyed the 888 dining experience, you know it’s not like your average Bay Area Italian restaurant. Conveniently located in the heart of downtown San Carlos, 888 Ristorante Italiano brings authentic flavors of Italy to Laurel Street. 888 was created from a passion for Italian cuisine that’s deep-rooted in the Maddalena family. Owner Vince Maddalena and Chef Raul learned their craft through growing up in the restaurant industry. Specifically, Maddalena’s, owned by Vince’s dad for over 30 years in Palo Alto. When Vince’s dad closed shop, Vince knew he wanted to continue sharing his passion for food with the public. And so 888 was born! When it comes to cooking, we never take shortcuts. Almost all of our menu is made in-house and we keep things fresh by changing our dishes as seasons come and go. Enjoy our intimate dining experience with a significant other, family and friends or just let us know if you have a large group and we would be happy to accommodate. Your host, Vincenzo Maddalena, would like to welcome you to his restaurant for a unique dining experience of authentic Italian cuisine. Buon Appetito!

Top review

JanGold

Dined on May 15, 2026

Always wonderful. Attentive staff great food lovely setting.

La Stanza Cucina Italiana

4.9

4.9 (714)

$30 and under

Italian

Menlo Park

About the restaurant

2020 We newly remodeled a warm and cozy Italian Sicilian restaurant we have two chefs owners in our kitchen preparing house made pasta and bread everyday please come and join us and taste our house made dishes. Angelo Cucco is from a small twon in Sicily and Miguel have ran a few kitchens in the peninsula come and let us make you feel a home

Top review

Laura

Dined 7 days ago

This is our favorite restaurant in the area. The food is fantastic. The service is amazing. It never disappoints.

Rocca Ristorante

4.9

4.9 (1831)

$30 and under

Italian

Burlingame

About the restaurant

Inspired by classic Northern Italian cooking with California influences, Rocca Ristorante features delicious veal, chicken, seafood and house made pastas – the signature Osso Bucco is not to be missed! The breathtaking décor boasts a spectacular Florentine copper & bronze high ceiling, whimsical murals and an elaborate Venetian-style balcony, all set in an enchanting Tuscan inspired setting. Wine connoisseurs will be impressed with the extensive collection of Italian and domestic selections. With our winning combination of warm and impeccable service, simple yet creative dishes and a passion for detail, Rocca Ristorante is the perfect place for your next dining experience.

Top review

PatriciaGold

Dined on May 21, 2026

Everything on the menu is predictably good! I eat there at least once a week. Great neighborhood vibe. Like eating at Cheers!

La Collina

4.8

4.8 (393)

$30 and under

Italian

Millbrae

About the restaurant

La Collina serves delicious, authentic regional Italian cuisine, in a casually elegant and comfortable setting. At La Collina’s, we strive to give each of our guests an outstanding dining experience, whether you’re here on a romantic date, or family and friends gathering. La Collina Restaurant serves delicious, authentic regional Italian cuisine, in a casually elegant and comfortable setting. La Collina Italian restaurant is a family run restaurant since 1996. It`s is an upscale Italian restaurant with a full bar specializing in authentic Italian cuisine. At La Collina Restaurant, you will enjoy Authentic Northern Italian food, including exquisite seafood dishes, pasta, veal, organic salads.

Top review

Roni

Dined 4 days ago

There was a great variety of fresh food that made our family members, who have different dietary preferences, enjoy a lot. Everything was delicious.

Cafe Pro Bono

4.9

4.9 (1523)

$30 and under

Italian

Palo Alto

About the restaurant

Cafe Pro Bono stands as Palo Alto's premier destination for exquisite Italian cuisine. With a legacy spanning over 30 years, we take pride in offering a diverse array of authentic and reasonably priced Italian and European dishes, each crafted with a dedication to freshness that is evident in every bite.

Whether you seek a romantic evening or a casual dinner, our menu features a wide selection of traditional dishes at accesible prices. From beautifully presented appetizers to homemade pastas, daily fresh seafood, quality meats, and indulgent desserts, complemented by expertly crafted cocktails we strive to ensure every visit is a memorable culinary experience.

Consider our Private Event Room for your next rehearsal dinner, birthday celebration, baby shower, family gathering or business meeting. Our full bar offers a variety of cocktails, including alongside domestic and international wines.

We look forward to welcoming you soon to Cafe Pro Bono.

Buon Appetito!!!

Top review

JacobGold

Dined 7 days ago

Great food all around. Loved the ambience and the service. Overall, a really nice spot if you're looking for some good Italian food in Palo Alto.

Discover more

Popular dish

Rigatoni

Divino Belmont

4.9

4.9 (1331)

$30 and under

Italian

Belmont

About the restaurant

Divino Ristorante serves delicious, authentic regional Italian cuisine, in a casually elegant and comfortable setting. Since first opening its doors on Ralston Avenue in Belmont, it has enjoyed rave reviews for its beautifully prepared and presented Italian fare and excellent service. Conveniently located on Ralston Avenue near El Camino Real, you can enjoy the freshest pasta, salads, seafood, veal, chicken and lamb dishes attractively presented with the experience of dining in Italy. Allow our professional staff to assist you in choosing the perfect wine from any region of Italy to perfectly complement your meal. For your next dinner with friends or family, or for a romantic dinner for two, you can count on Divino.

Top review

stefaniaGold

Dined on May 20, 2026

Pra was our server. She is attentive. We started with the Caprese, vitello Marsala and tiramisù & coffee. Everything was delicious. I continue to bring everyone (friends & family) I can, here😉 We have held family dinners and @ least (3) large birthday celebrations in your private room with Catalino & Pra. P.S. I miss my “birthday” tiramisu from Catalino complete with pink candle! My bestie & I were unable to get together on the exact date, a li’l late this year.

Discover more

Luceti's on 25th Avenue

4.8

4.8 (1012)

$31 to $50

Italian

San Mateo

About the restaurant

A taste of Tuscany and local treasure that is simply delicious. For over three decades, Luceti's has served Italian cuisine created by world class chef and awarded San Franciscan, Roger Bertola. Founder of the legendary Doro's, Ruggero's and master chef of Fior and the Iron Horse. Mr. Bertola was also the personal chef to generals Eisenhower and Paton. Today, Luceti's owners carry on the same tradition and cuisine that was started by Dr. Ron Luceti in 1984. Luceti's is a great place for private parties and business meetings.

Top review

NancyGold

Dined on May 21, 2026

The quality of the food is excellent. The meatballs are very tender and flavorful. The calamari was crisp and seasoned well. The staff is delightful.

Discover more

4.8

4.8 (578)

$30 and under

Italian

South San Francisco

About the restaurant

Located in the heart of downtown South San Francisco owner John Akkaya and Executive Chef, Angelo bring together a taste of Italy with a Mediterranean twist. Akkaya has been in the restaurant world for over 30 years with two additional Bay Area restaurants, Cafe Figaro in Burlingame and Don Giovanni in Mountain View. As he says himself, Andiamo In Banca is how he is celebrating years of experience in industry by combining the authentic Italian taste with hearty ingredients without losing the cozy experience.

Top review

claudiaGold

Dined on May 21, 2026

Fabulous authentic Italien dishes. Staff friendly and attentive! Have been there a few times. Always delighted.

Discover more

Popular dish

Mushroom Ravioli

Popular dish

Pappardelle Bolognese

Popular dish

Calamari Fritti

Original Joe's Westlake

4.8

4.8 (5796)

$30 and under

Italian

Daly City

About the restaurant

After a two-year closure, Original Joe's, San Francisco’s quintessential Italian-American dining destination, revitalized iconic Daly City institution Joe’s of Westlake, and reintroduced it into the community as Original Joe’s Westlake. An anchor of Daly City from 1956 to 2014, Original Joe’s Westlake underwent an extensive two-year renovation, complete with a front-to-back interior remodel, including the kitchen and all dining spaces, and an exterior and landscaping overhaul. Following the Original Joe’s tradition, Westlake continues to prepare unpretentious, old-school Italian-American fare in an open kitchen for all to see. The menu is carefully crafted to reflect a past-meets-present hybrid of what Joe’s of Westlake used to be and what Original Joe’s Westlake is today.

Top review

MoGold

Dined 4 days ago

I respected and enjoyed the fact that waiter was willing to split a salad between my wife and myself and for the first time since I’ve been going to Joe’s since 1959. I had the lamb chops. They are exquisite. That’s all I can say.

Discover more

4.6

4.6 (341)

$30 and under

Italian

Los Altos

About the restaurant

Cafe Vitale was born out of a passion in 2010 to offer fresh, high quality food to our local community. We wanted to create a place where friends and family could meet, relax and enjoy a wholesome meal, a healthful snack or a cup of coffee together. Whether it’s a casual meeting or a special occasion. We hope to create a hometown environment with an upscale flare. Our mission is to become an asset to our community, offering great food at competitive prices and extending excellent customer service.

Top review

MicheleGold

Dined on May 10, 2026

Excellent service. Delicious food! Looking forward to returning.

Explore Diners' Choice best of Peninsula

Explore more Diners' Choice lists